Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker 2024

The Coffee Folk is reader-supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

If you are short on space, a 4-cup coffee maker may be just the thing for you. These compact drip coffee makers are just the thing to pull out for special occasions

We have compiled a list of the best 4-cup coffee makers to help you in your journey towards producing the perfect cup of coffee.

Why Buy A Small Coffee Maker?

A 4-cup coffee maker is a good entry into the world of coffee. They are a good option if you are looking for a coffee maker to cater to a small household or simply a coffee lover who is not content with a single cup! A small coffee maker is quick and convenient to use and produces a decent cup of Joe. A prime example would be something like the Smeg coffee maker.

You will also find they are relatively compact, so can easily be stored away when not in use. You will find the coffee makers at this level are pretty basic. Often they will come with some sort of timer and auto-off function but very few other bells and whistles. If you are a coffee connoisseur it would be better to opt for a larger coffee maker like the Moccamaster or Breville Precision Brewer which are some of the best drip coffee makers on the market.

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker

Buying Guide

We have put together a list of a few things to consider before deciding on what would be the best 4-cup coffee maker.

Brewing Temperature

The first and most important thing to consider is the brewing temperature of the coffee maker. The ideal brewing temperature is between 195F and 205F. If your coffee maker is unable to brew coffee in this range then there really isn’t much point in buying it, as the coffee produced will be undrinkable. If the coffee is brewed at a temperature higher than 205F you will find it will be burnt. Conversely, if the coffee is brewed at a temperature lower than 195F it will be under-extracted and will taste sour.

Brewing Speed

The second thing to consider is how long it will take for your coffee maker to brew a pot of coffee. Ideally, you want a coffee maker that won’t take too long to brew a pot, for convenience’s sake. A lot of coffee makers also come with a pause brew option so you can grab a cup before it’s finished brewing the whole pot full. The brewing speed also affects the quality of the coffee produced. NCAUSA recommends a brewing time of 5 minutes for drip or filter coffee. If the brew time is too short the coffee will be under-extracted and taste sour. Or if it is too long it will be over-extracted and taste bitter.


Some of the coffee makers at this level come with a timer you can set for the machine to make coffee automatically. This means you can enjoy that fresh pot of coffee when the alarm clock goes off. 


Consider what type of carafe the coffee maker comes with. There are generally 3 options: stainless steel, plastic, or glass. Stainless steel is probably the best option, with most thermal carafes being made of this. It has a nice finish and is very sturdy. Plastic is a cheaper option that is still pretty durable but does not have the best aesthetics and can also confer some unpleasant flavors to your brew. Glass is another popular option as it doesn’t detract from the brew. Glass is easy to clean and allows you to see the coffee brewing, however, it is fragile and doesn’t keep the coffee warm for long.

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker 2024

Bonavita 5-Cup Coffee Maker

Best Small Coffee Maker

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker

While not strictly a 4-cup coffee maker the Bonavita is our pick as the best small coffee maker. This coffee maker ticks all the boxes when it comes to brewing a great cup of coffee and is popular among the specialty coffee crowds. It features a showerhead which disperses a steady and consistent pour of water over the grounds. The water is heated to around 200-203F and remains at that temperature throughout the brewing process. 

It also has a pre-infusion function which saturates the ground coffee and allows it to degas before brewing. The coffee maker comes with a stainless steel carafe which, while sufficient, has been reported to not be all that good at keeping the coffee hot, and is also difficult to pour from. Overall, the Bonavita coffee maker is a great option that looks great, and is made by a well known and respected brand. Bonavita’s big brother (the 8-cup coffee maker) is also certified by the SCAA.

Cuisinart 4-Cup Coffee Maker

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker

If you are looking for a small and basic coffee maker then the Cuisinart 4-cup coffee maker may just be for you! It comes with a stainless steel carafe fit out with a knuckle guard – as it does get hot! This really is a very simple coffee maker with the only extra feature being a brew pause capability so you can grab a cup before its finished brewing. Other than that it has a 30 minute auto shut off feature and that’s about it! It’s compact size makes it a good option if you are looking for a coffee maker for an RV. Overall this is a sturdy, simple and reliable coffee maker at a very affordable price.

Zojirushi Zutto 5-Cup Coffee Maker

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker

The Zojirushi Zutto is a nice looking coffee maker with a sleek and simple design. The main differentiation between this and the other coffee makers is that the Zojirushi comes with a built in charcoal water filter to help improve the taste of the coffee. The filter lasts for up to 2 years with regular use. It also comes with a glass carafe and an automatic keep warm function. On the downside the Zojirushi Zutto has no programmability and is mostly made of plastic. Overall though, this is a stylish and thoughtfully designed coffee maker.

Mr Coffee 4-Cup Coffee Maker

Best 4-Cup Coffee Makers

No list would be complete without a mention of a Mr Coffee Coffee maker! This is really the go to if you are looking for a budget coffee maker. While basic it does everything you need it to. It has a pause brew function so you can grab a cup mid-brew. It comes with a glass carafe and a removable filter basket for easy cleaning. Overall this is a classic coffee maker that is compact and affordable.

Black + Decker Coffee Maker

Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker

This coffee maker has a simple, no-nonsense design that’s easy to use for coffee enthusiasts of all skill levels. It comes with a 5-cup glass carafe that sits on a hot plate that can keep your coffee warm for up to an hour after brewing. The coffee maker also has a handy sneak-a-cup feature where you can pause brewing to pour yourself a cup of fresh coffee rather than wait for it to brew a whole pot full.

The Black and Decker coffee maker also features a water window with markings of how much water to fill it for each cup size. This is great if you are just wanting to make a couple of cups of coffee rather than the full 5 cup capacity. When it comes to the quality of the coffee produced, there are some reports of it being rather weak. This is because of the design of the coffee maker, where the water runs quickly through the coffee grounds. Overall this is a great option if you are looking for a compact, affordable coffee maker that is convenient to use and can cater to larger groups.

The Best 4-Cup Coffee Maker?

Well after reviewing the best 4 cup coffee makers our final verdict is that it is actually a 5-cup coffee maker that wins the day! The Bonavita Coffee Maker is our top pick as the best small coffee maker. Overall this is a well made coffee maker by a reliable brand that is known to produce good tasting coffee. At this price range, you will find most of the coffee makers are relatively budget and limited in programmability. If you are a coffee connoisseur we would recommend investing in a larger coffee maker that has been recommended by the SCAA. However if you are just starting your coffee journey, the Bonavita is a great buy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *